I Am Not a Driver. I Am Not a Gig Economy Analyst. I Am a Passenger.
Most Uber reviews are written from the outside. A journalist tests the app for two weeks, writes about features, and moves on. That is fine. This is not that. I sold my car in early 2023 and have been using Uber as my primary transportation in Bangalore, India, for three years. My Uber account says I have taken 1,847 rides. That is not a typo. That is about twelve rides per week, including weekends. I have spent more time in the back seats of Uber cars than most people spend commuting by any method.
I am going to review Uber the way I would review a pair of shoes I have worn every day for three years. I know where it pinches. I know where it holds up. I know the things that only reveal themselves after hundreds of uses, not two weeks of testing. And I am going to organize this around the situations where I actually use the app, because the experience varies so wildly depending on context that a single summary would be dishonest.
The Commute: Monday Through Friday, 8:45 AM and 6:30 PM
My office is in Whitefield. I live in Indiranagar. That is about 13 kilometers, which takes anywhere from 25 minutes to 75 minutes depending on traffic. I know those numbers by heart because I have lived them a thousand times.
At 8:45 AM, getting an UberX in Indiranagar takes about four minutes. The fare is usually between 280 and 350 rupees (roughly $3.30-$4.20). That is remarkably consistent. I have tracked it. On maybe 10% of mornings, there is a 1.2x to 1.5x surge, which pushes the fare to about 400 rupees. Annoying but manageable. The 8:45 AM window is interesting because the worst surge happens earlier -- around 9:15 to 9:45 when the office rush peaks. I adjusted my schedule to avoid it. Uber has trained me to commute at odd hours, which I suppose is the market working as intended.
The evening commute is worse. By 6:30 PM, leaving Whitefield is a war zone. Surge pricing hits 1.5x to 2x almost every weekday evening. The same trip that cost 300 rupees in the morning costs 500+ rupees coming home. Wait times stretch to 8-12 minutes. Drivers cancel more often because they do not want to sit in Whitefield traffic. On bad days -- rain, festivals, Friday evenings -- I have waited 20 minutes for a ride and paid 2.5x surge. That is $7.50 for a 13-kilometer ride, which does not sound terrible in isolation but feels insulting when you know what the base fare should be.
Over three years, my commute costs average about 28,000 rupees per month ($335). That is more than a monthly car payment for a decent hatchback. But when I add insurance, fuel, parking at both locations, maintenance, and the stress of driving in Bangalore traffic myself, the math still favors Uber. Barely. The equation only works because I can sit in the back seat and work on my laptop during the commute. That hour of productive time is the real value, not the ride itself.
Late Night: The Reason I Kept the App
If I could only use Uber for one purpose, it would be late-night rides. Before Uber, getting home safely after 11 PM in Bangalore meant either driving yourself (not great after a dinner with wine), calling an auto-rickshaw driver who may or may not show up, or standing on MG Road hoping a metered taxi would stop. None of these options were good. The auto-rickshaw option was the worst -- negotiating a fare with a stranger on a dark street while slightly tipsy is exactly the kind of vulnerability that ride-hailing was invented to eliminate.
With Uber, I request a ride from inside the restaurant. I see the driver's name, photo, vehicle number, and rating before they arrive. My friend can track my trip in real-time through Share My Trip. The PIN verification means I cannot accidentally get into the wrong car. And if anything feels wrong, the safety shield is one tap away. After 1,847 rides, only twice has a driver made me uncomfortable (aggressive driving both times), and in both cases, I reported it through the app and received a follow-up from Uber's safety team within hours.
Late-night pricing is actually reasonable in Bangalore. After 11 PM, demand drops and so does surge. A ride home from Koramangala to Indiranagar at midnight usually costs 200-250 rupees with no surge. At 2 AM, the wait time increases to 8-10 minutes, but a car always shows up eventually. I have never been stranded. In three years of late-night rides, the longest I waited was 18 minutes on a Diwali night, and even that felt miraculous compared to the pre-Uber alternative of nothing.
The Airport Run: Where Uber Reserve Earns Its Keep
Kempegowda International Airport is 40 kilometers from my apartment. That is at least an hour drive, and with traffic it can be ninety minutes. For a 6 AM flight, I need to leave by 3:30 AM. There was a time when I would set an alarm for 3:00 AM, open the app in a half-asleep panic, and pray that a driver was available. Sometimes one was. Sometimes I waited fifteen minutes while my departure anxiety compounded. Once, I waited twenty-two minutes and nearly missed check-in.
Uber Reserve fixed this. I book the ride up to a week in advance. The fare is locked -- no surge, no surprises. A driver is assigned ahead of time and arrives ten minutes before the scheduled pickup. I have used Reserve for airport rides maybe thirty times, and the driver has never been late. Not once. They wait in the parking lot. They call to confirm. The professionalism of Reserve drivers is noticeably higher than random UberX drivers, probably because the assignment process favors top-rated, reliable drivers.
The premium for Reserve is about 15-20% over what a standard ride would cost at the same time. For a 3:30 AM airport run, that works out to roughly 200 rupees extra. Absolutely worth it for the guarantee. Missing a flight costs more than any Uber premium.
The return trip from the airport is a different story. The designated pickup area at Kempegowda is well-organized, but demand after evening flights creates consistent surge. I have paid 1.8x on a Tuesday evening landing, which felt excessive. The alternative -- the airport taxi queue -- is cheaper but slower and less predictable. I usually default to Uber anyway because I am tired and just want to get home without negotiating.
Uber Eats: Convenience with a Guilt Tax
I order Uber Eats about three times a week. I am not proud of this. My kitchen works. I can cook. But after a long day, the path of least resistance is opening the app, tapping the biryani place I have ordered from 43 times (Uber shows you the count, which is mildly humiliating), and waiting 35 minutes for it to arrive.
The food is fine. The delivery reliability is good -- maybe one in fifteen orders has an issue, usually a missing drink or a delayed delivery time. The interface is clean and fast. The restaurant selection in Bangalore is excellent, covering everything from hole-in-the-wall biryanis to upscale sushi places.
The cost, though. Let me walk you through the math on my most frequent order: a chicken biryani and a butter naan from a restaurant I could drive to in eight minutes. At the restaurant, the biryani is 280 rupees and the naan is 80 rupees. Total: 360 rupees. On Uber Eats, the biryani is listed at 310 rupees and the naan at 95 rupees (menu markup). Subtotal: 405 rupees. Then add delivery fee: 35 rupees. Platform fee: 10 rupees. Small order fee (sometimes): 30 rupees. Packaging charges: 15 rupees. Final total: roughly 495 rupees. That is a 37% premium over walking into the restaurant and ordering the same food. My Uber One membership removes the delivery fee, bringing it to about 460 rupees, but that is still a 28% premium.
I keep paying it. That says more about my laziness than about Uber Eats' value proposition. But I want to be clear-eyed: food delivery is an expensive convenience, and the layers of fees that Uber adds make it more expensive than it looks at first glance. If you are budget-conscious, pick up your own food. If you value your time more than the markup, Uber Eats works well.
The Small Things After 1,847 Rides
Your expectations calibrate over time. Here are the things I notice now that I never thought about at the beginning.
Car quality varies wildly. I have ridden in spotless, air-conditioned hatchbacks with bottled water in the cup holder, and I have ridden in cars that smelled like the driver had been smoking with the windows up. The rating system is supposed to filter this, but a 4.7-rated driver can have a great attitude and a terrible car, or vice versa. Uber does not rate cars independently from drivers, and it should.
Driver cancellations are the biggest daily frustration. In Bangalore, about one in five ride requests gets cancelled by the driver. They accept the ride, see your destination, decide it is not worth the traffic or the distance, and cancel. Then you request again. And sometimes the next driver cancels too. I have had three consecutive cancellations on a single ride request during peak hours. Uber penalizes driver cancellations, but whatever the penalty is, it is clearly not enough to stop the behavior.
The route algorithm sometimes makes bizarre choices. It will send me through narrow residential lanes instead of the wider main road because the GPS thinks the lane is two minutes faster. The driver and I both know the main road is the better choice, but the app's navigation is insistent. Most experienced drivers ignore the GPS and take the sensible route, which ironically makes the fare tracking slightly less accurate since the fare is calculated on the actual path, not the suggested one.
Tipping culture is awkward. Uber asks you to tip after every ride. Most riders in India do not tip through the app -- the tipping culture around ride-hailing has not fully developed here the way it has in the US. I tip in cash occasionally for exceptional service but not for every ride, and I feel a small pang of guilt every time I dismiss the tipping screen. The drivers who deserve tips the most -- the ones who are polite, keep their car clean, and drive safely -- are rarely the ones who hint at wanting one.
Uber One: Does the Membership Make Sense?
I have had Uber One for about eight months. In India, it costs 149 rupees per month (about $1.80). That is drastically cheaper than the US price of $9.99/month, which gives you a sense of how region-specific Uber's pricing strategy is. The benefits: free delivery on Uber Eats orders over 149 rupees, 5% off rides, 5% off Eats orders, and priority support.
At my usage level -- twelve rides and three Eats orders per week -- the 5% ride discount alone saves me about 1,400 rupees per month. The free delivery saves another 400 or so. Total savings: roughly 1,800 rupees on a 149-rupee membership. That is a 12x return, which is absurd. Even at lower usage -- say, four rides per week and one Eats order -- the membership pays for itself easily. For regular Uber users in India, Uber One is a no-brainer at this price point.
The priority support benefit is real but rare. The one time I needed it -- a driver took a route that was thirty minutes longer than necessary, inflating the fare -- I got through to a human in under two minutes through Uber One support. Without it, the typical wait for Uber support in India is "submit a complaint and hope someone reads it in 48 hours." For that one interaction alone, the membership was worth eight months of subscription fees.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Late-night safety alone justifies the app's existence -- reliable rides home after dark with tracking and accountability
- Uber Reserve has never let me down for airport pickups, and the guaranteed pricing removes departure-day stress
- Uber One membership at Indian pricing is the best value subscription I pay for
- The app works consistently -- in three years, I can count the true technical failures on one hand
- Upfront pricing removes the fare-negotiation anxiety that used to define transportation in Indian cities
- Works identically when I travel -- I have used the same app in Mumbai, Delhi, London, and Singapore without changing anything
Cons
- Driver cancellations in Bangalore are relentless and Uber's penalties clearly do not deter them
- Evening surge pricing turns a budget-friendly commute into a premium expense multiple times per week
- Uber Eats fees stack up to 30-40% over restaurant prices, making regular use genuinely expensive
- Car quality is inconsistent and the rating system does not separate driver behavior from vehicle condition
- Route algorithm sometimes makes decisions that no local human would agree with
- Customer support without Uber One is essentially an automated reply machine
What I Spend: The Honest Numbers
I tracked every Uber transaction for six months. Here is where my money actually goes. Commute rides: roughly 20,000 INR/month ($240). Non-commute rides (errands, social, medical): about 5,000 INR/month ($60). Uber Eats: about 6,000 INR/month ($72). Uber One: 149 INR/month ($1.80). Grand total: approximately 31,150 INR/month ($374).
For context, the EMI on a Maruti Baleno (a popular hatchback) is about 18,000 INR/month. Insurance is another 3,000. Fuel at my distance would be about 6,000. Parking at home and office: 3,000. Maintenance averaged monthly: 2,000. Total car ownership: roughly 32,000 INR/month. Almost identical to my Uber spend, but with the added costs of my time spent driving, the stress of Bangalore traffic, and the upfront down payment I would have needed.
The math is roughly break-even, which means the decision comes down to preferences, not economics. I prefer sitting in the back seat answering emails. Someone else prefers the independence of their own vehicle. Neither is wrong.
The Question I Cannot Answer
After 1,847 rides, I know my drivers in a pattern-recognition way. Most are men between 25 and 45. Many drive 10-12 hours per day. Some do it full-time. Others supplement another income. They are unfailingly polite, usually because their rating depends on it. When I ask how the work is going, the honest ones say it is getting harder. Fewer incentives than before. Higher fuel costs. The commission Uber takes -- around 25-30% in India -- leaves them with less than you might think. After fuel, vehicle maintenance, and the car loan many of them are paying, the net hourly income for an Uber driver in Bangalore is somewhere around 80-120 rupees ($1-$1.50). That is above minimum wage for Karnataka, but not by a comfortable margin.
I think about this more than I would like to. I benefit from a system that keeps transportation costs low by keeping driver compensation low. The convenience I enjoy is directly connected to someone else's economic precariousness. The app design keeps this invisible -- you see a car, a price, and a rating, not a person calculating whether they can afford their daughter's school fees this month. That invisibility is a feature of the product, and I am not sure whether it is a good one.
I am not going to solve the gig economy question in a product review. Smarter people than me have been debating it for years. But I will say this: if you use Uber regularly, tip your drivers. Not because the app asks you to. Because the person driving you home at midnight is probably earning less than you think, and a small gesture of recognition is the least we can offer in a system that is designed to make their labor feel like a commodity.
Rating: 4.0 / 5
Uber has replaced my car, my auto-rickshaw negotiations, my late-night anxieties, and my airport logistics. It has also replaced a significant chunk of my cooking and my restaurant visits. For better or worse, it is woven into my daily life in a way that no other app except maybe my phone's messaging app can claim.
It is not perfect. The surge pricing is aggressive. The driver cancellations are maddening. The Eats markup is steep. And the ethical question about driver compensation lingers in the back seat of every ride I take.
But I have not bought a car in three years, and I do not plan to buy one. That tells you everything a rating number cannot. 4.0 out of 5 from the back seat.
Fellow Bangalore rider here. The Whitefield evening surge is brutal and your numbers match mine almost exactly. Have you tried Rapido autos for the commute? I switched my evening commute to Rapido and save about 40% versus Uber, though the experience is obviously less comfortable.
The section about driver compensation really got to me. I have been using Uber in London for years and never really thought about what the driver takes home after all the deductions. Going to start tipping consistently. Thanks for writing this honestly instead of just reviewing features.
I drive for Uber in Hyderabad and your estimate of 80-120 INR per hour net is accurate, maybe even optimistic for the off-peak hours. The commission structure has gotten worse over the past two years. The best time for drivers is festival season when the bonuses kick in. Rest of the year is a grind.